What Can You Appeal in a California Workers’ Comp Case?
In workers’ comp, “appealing” means asking a judge, or another neutral reviewer, to overrule the insurance company. You can challenge:
- A denied claim, when the insurance company says your injury isn’t covered
- Stopped or reduced disability checks
- Denied medical treatment, like surgery, an MRI or therapy
- A doctor’s report you disagree with, like one that says you can go back to work
- A permanent disability rating you think is too low
- A judge’s decision in your case
If your claim was just denied, start with what to do when your workers’ comp claim is denied. This page covers the formal appeal process that comes next.
The Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB)
Most workers’ comp disputes in California are decided by the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board, often called the WCAB. Despite the name, it’s not just for appeals. It’s the court system for workers’ comp cases.
The WCAB has local offices across the state, where workers’ comp judges hold hearings and trials. In Southern California, cases are heard at district offices including Van Nuys, Los Angeles, Long Beach, Santa Ana, Riverside, San Bernardino and Oxnard. Your case is usually heard at the office near where you live, where you were hurt, or where your lawyer’s office is.
A separate group of commissioners, also part of the WCAB, reviews judges’ decisions when someone asks for reconsideration.
The Workers’ Comp Appeal Process, Step by Step
Here’s how a typical California workers’ comp appeal moves forward when the insurance company won’t change its mind:
- File an Application for Adjudication of Claim. This form opens a case with the WCAB. You’ll get a case number, called an ADJ number, that goes on every document from then on.
- Gather your evidence. This includes medical records, doctor’s reports, your denial letter, proof of when you reported the injury and statements from witnesses. Sometimes you’ll need an exam from a neutral doctor (more on that below).
- File a Declaration of Readiness to Proceed. This form tells the court you’re ready for a hearing.
- Go to a Mandatory Settlement Conference. This must be held between 10 and 30 days after you file the Declaration of Readiness. A judge meets with both sides to try to settle the case. Many cases are resolved here.
- Go to trial if the case doesn’t settle. The law says trial should be held within 75 days after you filed the Declaration of Readiness, though busy courts can take longer. A workers’ comp judge hears testimony, looks at the evidence and decides the case. There’s no jury.
- Get the judge’s decision. The judge issues a written decision, usually called a Findings and Award.
Expedited Hearings for Urgent Issues
Some problems can’t wait months. For issues like stopped disability checks or certain medical treatment disputes, you can ask for an expedited hearing. The law requires the hearing and decision within 30 days after you file the Declaration of Readiness.
Not sure why your checks stopped? Our guide explains what can end your benefits early and when an insurer is allowed to do it.
How to Appeal a Workers’ Comp Judge’s Decision
If you disagree with the judge’s decision, you can ask the WCAB commissioners to review it. This is called a Petition for Reconsideration.
- Deadline: You must file within 20 days of when the decision was served on you. If it was mailed to you, you usually get 5 extra days. Missing this deadline usually means losing your right to appeal.
- Reasons you can appeal: for example, the evidence doesn’t support the decision, the judge made a legal mistake or went beyond their power, there’s important new evidence, or the decision was based on fraud.
- What happens next: The judge who decided your case writes a report, then sends the case to the commissioners. The commissioners have 60 days from when the case is sent to them to act. If they don’t act in time, the petition is treated as denied.
Going to the Court of Appeal
If the commissioners deny your petition or rule against you, you can ask a California Court of Appeal to review the case. This is called a Petition for Writ of Review, and it must be filed within 45 days. Few cases go this far, and the courts only take a small number of them, but it’s an important option in cases with big legal questions.
Other Workers’ Comp Disputes: Denied Treatment and Doctor Reports
Not every dispute goes straight to a judge. California has separate processes for two common problems.
When Medical Treatment Is Denied: Independent Medical Review
If the insurance company denies treatment your doctor asked for, like surgery or physical therapy, you can ask for Independent Medical Review (IMR). An outside doctor reviews your records and decides if the treatment should be approved.
- You must ask for IMR within 30 days of getting the denial.
- It’s free to you. The insurance company pays.
- An IMR decision is very hard to appeal. You can only challenge it for a few narrow reasons, like fraud, a conflict of interest or a clear mistake of fact. That’s why the first request needs to be strong.
When You Disagree With a Doctor’s Report: QMEs
If you or the insurance company disagree with what your treating doctor says, like whether your injury happened at work, whether you can go back to work, or how bad your permanent disability is, the dispute is usually settled by a Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME). A QME is a state-certified doctor who examines you and writes a report.
If you don’t have a lawyer, you’ll usually get a list of three QMEs, called a panel, to choose from. If you have a lawyer, both sides may agree on a doctor instead. The QME’s report often carries a lot of weight with the judge, so preparing for that exam matters.
Workers’ Comp Appeal Deadlines in California
Deadlines in workers’ comp are strict. Missing one can mean losing your right to benefits. Here are the key ones:
What you’re doing | Deadline |
|---|
Report your injury to your employer | Within 30 days of the injury |
File your workers’ comp claim | Usually within 1 year of the injury |
Ask for Independent Medical Review of denied treatment | Within 30 days of the denial |
Settlement conference after you file a Declaration of Readiness | Between 10 and 30 days |
Expedited hearing and decision on urgent issues | Within 30 days of filing |
Ask for reconsideration of a judge’s decision | Within 20 days of service, usually plus 5 days if mailed |
WCAB commissioners act on reconsideration | Within 60 days of getting the case |
Ask the Court of Appeal to review the WCAB’s decision | Within 45 days |
Other deadlines can apply in your case, like a one-year deadline for a claim that your employer broke safety rules. A lawyer can track every deadline for you.
How Long Does a Workers’ Comp Appeal Take?
It depends on how complicated your case is and how busy your local WCAB office is. A case that settles at the settlement conference can wrap up in a few months. A case that goes to trial can take longer, and a request for reconsideration adds at least a few more months. Expedited hearings for urgent issues, like stopped checks, move much faster.
The best way to avoid delays is to have your medical evidence ready early. Cases often stall while waiting for doctor’s reports.
Why Hire a Workers’ Comp Appeal Lawyer?
You have the right to handle an appeal on your own. But the insurance company will have its own lawyer at every hearing, and appeals come with forms, rules and deadlines that are easy to miss. A workers’ comp appeal lawyer can:
- File the right forms on time, so your case isn’t thrown out on a technicality
- Build your evidence, including medical records, witness statements and reports from the right doctors
- Prepare you for your QME exam, your deposition and your testimony at trial
- Negotiate at the settlement conference, where many cases are resolved
- Represent you at trial in front of the workers’ comp judge
- File for reconsideration if the judge gets it wrong
In California, cases where the injured worker has a lawyer are also placed on a priority court calendar. Talking to us is free, and a workers’ comp lawyer’s fee comes out of your benefits, with a judge’s approval. Learn more about how a workers’ comp attorney can help you.